I have been running a code to simulate energy deposition by xrays in the 50 keV - 10 MeV energy range for a medical physics problem. Up until now, I have always run the beam in along the z-axis. Yesterday, I introduced variable direction beams (so I could sum over multiple doses) and got a surprise. The energy deposition around beams not running along te z-axis is very asymmetrical with the +z axis being preferred to the -z axis in G4PenelopeCompton events. Changing G4PenelopeCompton to G4LowEnergyCompton produces the expected result with the energy deposition symmetrical about the beam axis. I have posted images of the energy deposition for each case at the URL listed below. The files of interest are image_lowenergy.jpg and image_penelope.jpg. The problem is immediately visible in the Penelope image. I will try to start poking around PenelopeCompton for this, but someone who is really familiar with the Penelope physics package might have a better shot at finding it quickly.
*** Bug 585 has been marked as a duplicate of this bug. *** *** 'Maria.Grazia.Pia@cern.ch' will be responsible for bug 585. ***
Corrected link to user's page.
This problem report is superseded by Problem Report 585, that contains the correct version of the problem.