Problem 1408 - energy not conserved in atomic deexcitation following radioactive decay
Summary: energy not conserved in atomic deexcitation following radioactive decay
Status: RESOLVED FIXED
Alias: None
Product: Geant4
Classification: Unclassified
Component: processes/hadronic (show other problems)
Version: 9.0
Hardware: All All
: P5 normal
Assignee: dennis.herbert.wright
URL:
Depends on:
Blocks:
 
Reported: 2012-12-13 20:19 CET by michel.maire
Modified: 2015-12-01 19:00 CET (History)
1 user (show)

See Also:


Attachments
plot of total energy after interaction (8.44 KB, image/gif)
2012-12-13 20:19 CET, michel.maire
Details

Note You need to log in before you can comment on or make changes to this problem.
Description michel.maire 2012-12-13 20:19:44 CET
Created attachment 197 [details]
plot of total energy after interaction

part of energy is lost in atomic deexcitation following an IT mode of radioactive decay. This does not happen in the atomic deexcitation following an electromagnetic process (e.g. photo electric effect)

I attach 2 macros for TestEm1. In gado1.mac, gamma 80 keV is shooted in Gadolinium. Gamma interacts by photoelectric effect. Then Gadolinium does cascade deexcitation. Plot is sum of energy of secondaries : it is perfectly 80 keV.

In gado2.mac, particleGun is an excited state of Gd158, which deexcite via RadioactiveDecay. Sum of energy of secondaries is not always 80 keV. 

I hope the plot is clear. 

 # Macro file for "TestEm1.cc"
#
#  Photon 80 keV; photoelectric effect
#
/control/verbose 2
/run/verbose 2
#
/testem/det/setMat G4_Gd
/testem/det/setSize 100 m
#
/testem/phys/addPhysics local
#
/run/initialize
#
# no Compton nor conversion
/process/inactivate compt
/process/inactivate conv
#
/process/em/fluo true
/process/em/auger true
#
/testem/phys/setCuts 1 um
#
/testem/gun/setDefault 
/gun/particle gamma
/gun/energy 80 keV
/gun/position 0 0 0 mm
#
###/testem/histo/setFileName gado1
###/testem/histo/setHisto 4 100 60 90 keV	#total edep
/analysis/setFileName gado1
/analysis/h1/set 4 100 60 90 keV	#total edep
#
/testem/event/printModulo 10000
#
/run/beamOn 100000


 # Macro file for "TestEm1.cc"
#
/control/verbose 2
/run/verbose 2
#
/testem/det/setMat Aluminium
/testem/det/setSize 100 m
#
/testem/phys/addPhysics  local
#
/run/initialize
#
/process/em/fluo true
/process/em/auger true
#
/testem/phys/setCuts 1 um
#
/testem/gun/setDefault
/gun/particle ion
/gun/ion 64 158 0 80 keV
/gun/energy 1 eV
/gun/position 0 0 0 mm
#
###/testem/histo/setFileName gado2
###/testem/histo/setHisto 4 100 60 90 keV	#total edep
/analysis/setFileName gado2
/analysis/h1/set 4 100 60 90 keV	#total edep
#	 
/testem/event/printModulo 10000
#
/run/beamOn 100000
#
Comment 1 dennis.herbert.wright 2013-01-28 18:07:30 CET
You have listed 9.0 as the version in which the problem occurs.  Since then many improvements have been made in energy conservation.  Please update to a more recent version to see if the problem improves.  We recently released version 9.6.
Comment 2 dennis.herbert.wright 2015-12-01 19:00:01 CET
In geant4-10-02-cand-02 I ran Gd158[79.513] in radioactive decay, and the mean
kinetic energy of the decay products was 79.535 keV, leading to an average energy non-conservation of 22 eV. So it appears there is no longer any large missing energy and this problem has been solved by the recent fixes to IT and EC.