Problem 1742

Summary: Muon-induced nuclear reactor in Geant4 10?
Product: Geant4 Reporter: Nicola Mori <mori>
Component: processes/hadronic/models/cascadeAssignee: Michael Kelsey <kelsey>
Status: RESOLVED WONTFIX    
Severity: normal CC: mori
Priority: P3    
Version: 10.0   
Hardware: All   
OS: All   
Attachments: Test program to reproduce the issue

Description Nicola Mori 2015-04-28 15:40:18 CEST
Created attachment 343 [details]
Test program to reproduce the issue

While simulating the passage of muons through an uranium target my simulation sometimes gets stuck. Investigating a bit deeper I found that the simulation actually runs, but that the event never finishes since many slow neutrons are generated inside the uranium, and they in turn induce some fission reactions which generate other neutrons and so on. The process looks similar to a "nuclear fission reactor". Typically, the reactor is ignited by a stopping muon or by a gamma. I see this behaviour very frequently compared to what one can reasonably expect: when running 10 instances of my simulation program, each one simulating 10^5 muons, typically one or two of them get stuck because of this mechanism

I have been able to put together a simple simulation to 
show off the problem. I attach a tarball containing the code and the CMakeLists
to reproduce the issue.

I tried this program on my 64 bit ArchLinux system with gcc 4.9.2. With Geant4 
10.00.p02 the simulation shows the "nuclear reactor" behaviour, while with 
Geant4 9.6.p03 the muon is stopped without producing any nuclear cascade. To 
better analyze what's going on during the simulation I applied this patch:

https://www.hightail.com/download/UlRUa3NVNkc3bUEwTWNUQw

to G4EventManager.cc to dump the secondaries. Here are the logs for the two
runs with 9.6.p03 and 10.00.p02 (I stopped the latter with Ctrl-C after a few 
seconds):

https://www.hightail.com/download/UlRUa3NVNkc3bURxYk1UQw
https://www.hightail.com/download/UlRUa3NVNkc3bUROUjhUQw

I don't know which behaviour is the correct one, and for what I know it could 
be due to changes in the code, changes in the models or  changes in the 
datasets (for each Geant4 version I used the datasets which are automatically 
installed when configuring the build with -DGEANT4_INSTALL_DATA=ON). Yet the 
two are really different so something must be wrong somewhere.
Comment 1 Nicola Mori 2015-04-28 15:41:27 CEST
The same problem is discussed on hypernews:

http://hypernews.slac.stanford.edu/HyperNews/geant4/get/hadronprocess/1457.html
Comment 2 Michael Kelsey 2015-04-28 23:12:47 CEST
I have summarized our validation tests for muon-stopping with the BERT cascade in Hypernews (http://hypernews.slac.stanford.edu/HyperNews/geant4/get/hadronprocess/1457/1/1/1/1.html).  

We believe that the cascade model is performing correctly, reproducing the expected secondary neutron spectrum.  It is possible that the rate of muon-induced fission is "too high," but without experimental data we don't have a simple way to valdidate that, or to adjust the model properly.